Bins farce costs £50k to clear up
WASTE bosses are ploughing £50,000 into clearing the city's unemptied bins backlog.
And the city council has apologised for the problems created by a complete overhaul of its collection system.
-

it's rubbish: Mr Banwait, left, on his protest outside the Council House with press officer Maureen Eastgate and environmental services' Paul Robinson. Picture: Ian Hodgkinson IH180210A-8
Meanwhile the authority, which has been under fire for allowing green and normal waste to be mixed, has vowed it will not happen again.
It also revealed that "it is dealing'' with the staff member who issued orders for binmen to mix the refuse in a desperate attempt to get on top of the issue of missed bins.
Paul Robinson, corporate director for environmental services, said the orders had not been approved by the council and the practice had been stopped as soon as it came to light.
"We apologise for the difficulties some customers have encountered as we have gone through this major change," he said. "We are working to bring back customer satisfaction levels."
Yesterday, Labour councillor Ranjit Banwait joined Alvaston resident Colin Brown as he took the contents of his unemptied bin to the Council House in protest over missed collections.
Mr Brown said his bin had not been emptied for four weeks.
"I just can't understand why they changed the system in the first place. The old one worked fine and the bins were always emptied on time but now it's just chaos," he said.
But the council said the old bin collection system did need changing to make it more up-to-date and to cope with an extra 6,000 homes being added to its kerbside recycling scheme.
The authority has been adding new properties to bin crews' rounds for many years as homes were built. But it meant the rounds were not evenly spread, with some crews working nine-hour days and others five hours.
On top of that, the council decided to expand its recycling scheme from the end of January but these could not be added to existing rounds which were already full, so the council reviewed its system.
Mr Robinson said: "The first option would have seen 99% of residents' having the day their bins were collected changed. That would have caused chaos.
"We, therefore, asked for another option to be created which would mean no changes in collection day for the majority of households."
The result was a system which saw 96% of households stay on the same collection day but instead the change was passed on to the bin crews who were put on to unfamiliar rounds.
It has caused delays as the staff have had to get used to new streets and rounds, meaning not all the bins have been reached on their usual days.
Mr Robinson said, however, that about 99% of the 180,000 bins the authority collects each week had not been affected and that the council was doing "everything possible" to sort out issues with the remaining 1%.
That includes paying £20 extra per day to staff – or £50,000 in total – for the first six weeks since the new rounds system came into operation.
This pays for additional collections and extra time spent on the paperwork needed to provide management with details of areas where there are problems.
A collection system has also been brought in to empty trade waste bins which have been missed.
Mr Robinson said some changes had been made.
"Some rounds have been tweaked with this feedback because what looks good on a computer programme sometimes needs adjusting in reality because of things like traffic playing a part in the time it takes to do rounds," he said.
It could take two more weeks for the service to get back to normal, as the council said it needed three complete cycles of the fortnightly bin collections – or six weeks from the new system's start date of January 25 – to resolve all the issues.
Last week the city council received 1,100 calls about missed bins – out of 180,000 it collects each week.







7 Comments
by Uncle Bill, Derby
Saturday, February 20 2010, 9:32AM
“Lucy, the bin men have already had their wages cut and been completely shafted by this management, yes i agree you should do a fair days work for a fair days pay but may be the people actually doing the job know the best ways around their routes. Put the managers on a bin crew and let them do the job for a day after all they get paid treble what the bin men get and they may earn some respect from the crews.”
by Lucy, Derby
Friday, February 19 2010, 3:41PM
“Sack the management, spread the saving out amongst the bin men who do a great job. Uncle Bill, Derby
Uncle Bill I will hav to disagree. The only reason bins aren't being emptied is because the bin crews are on a go slow. Before the new rounds came into place the crew were allowed to go home once they had completed their route. This meant that they could work for 4 hours and get paid for 7 1/2. Now the rounds are fairer the crews don't like because god forbid they are actually being paid for a days work. The crews are just proving a point. They are already getting an extra £20 per week each for the first six weeks, what more do they want!”
by Uncle Bill, Derby
Friday, February 19 2010, 2:40PM
“Sack the management, spread the saving out amongst the bin men who do a great job.”
by Tom, Derby
Friday, February 19 2010, 11:36AM
“I see the Lib Dems are out in force.........Perhaps what Billy and Dave miss out is that this farce was caused by poor preperation from the City Council leadership. All Banwait has done is hi-light how bad the City Council has become on this and other issues, just remember this is the same group of people who campaigned to keep Bramblebrook Care Home open in opposition only to then propose shutting all residential homes. Proposed to close all City Centre toilets before 11,000 people said no. I note that they have done a U Turn on the Allenton CCTV camera's, now who was it who did a hi profile campaign on that issue? ah yes Cllr Banwait. So Cllr Banwait if the issue is right keep jumping on that 'bandwagon' and show this inept lot up for what they are.”
by Mary, Derby
Friday, February 19 2010, 9:36AM
“Less we forget this man (and I use the word loosey) wanted to bring you congestion charge! He is the problem in Derby. Get him out on 6th May!”
by Dave, Derby
Friday, February 19 2010, 9:28AM
“All is well. Banwait is on his trolley again.”
by Billy, Derby
Friday, February 19 2010, 9:07AM
“What a pathetic excuse for a Councillor Mr Bandwagon is.
He would be better employed trying to assist in getting this situation resolved and ensuring it doesn't happen again.
I must say that looks suspiciously like a Council owned trolley Councillor, i cannot imagine you brought that to the Council House in your car....”