Bloodstained clothes banned from protests outside factory

Trusted article source icon
Thursday, August 04, 2011
Profile image for Derby Telegraph

Derby Telegraph

A CHAIN of laboratories engaged in breeding animals for medical research has won a High Court injunction banning protesters wearing bloodstained clothing outside its offices.

Harlan Laboratories UK is the subject of demonstrations at four sites it operates in Derbyshire, Leicestershire, Cambridgeshire and Oxfordshire.

Protests by the National Anti-Vivisection Alliance (NAVA) and backed by Stop Huntingdon Animal Cruelty (SHAC) began in April, and have been marked by activists sporting blood-stained costumes, which they say represent the "slaughter" of animals.

The protests at Shardlow in Derbyshire, Belton in Leicestershire, Wyton in Cambridgeshire and Blackthorn in Oxfordshire were curtailed by an injunction issued last month under the Protection From Harassment Act.

It limited the protests at each site to one a week and cut the numbers allowed to demonstrate to 20. It also banned protesters wearing bloodstained attire.

The High Court yesterday relaxed some of the restrictions on the protesters but, after heated argument, refused to allow bloodstained clothing.

Tim Lawson-Cruttenden, representing Harlan, told Mrs Justice Nicola Davies the company's employees were entitled to "respect" as they go about their work and that being confronted with blood-spattered campaigners amounted to harassment.

He told the court in London: "Most of our employees are concerned with the husbandry of animals. We have a very small research establishment but we don't conduct any vivisection. We are trying to stop the wearing of this bloodstained clothing.

"We have the right to respect. We are breeding animals for medical research, which is both legal and, we believe, moral. The defendants think it should not be legal and is not moral and that is where we differ.

"We find it very objectionable and potentially harassing when our workers come out of the factory gate – in which they have been working hard, lawfully and morally – to be faced with protesters accusing them of something they don't do, which is abusing animals and practising vivisection experiments on them.

"When you wear blood-stained clothing outside our premises, you are calling our workers animal abusers."

Luke Steele, a spokesman for NAVA, told the judge: "It is the case for the defence that Harlan Laboratories are involved in slaughtering animals at these sites and a number of animals are killed on site each year that cannot be sold.

"The bloodstained clothing is there to represent the fact that Harlan are involved in slaughtering animals and supplying them for medical research."

Mr Steele said the campaigners were exercising the right of public protest and the right to draw attention to their cause through wearing costumes.

Mrs Justice Nicola Davies said: "I accept that the defendants have a right to protest, but that must be balanced with other rights.

"The workers leaving the factory and seeing bloodstained clothing are capable of being caused harassment and distress," she said

The judge directed that the ban be maintained until a full hearing, set for October, but relaxed other restrictions on the protests, increasing the maximum number of demonstrators to 25 and extending their permitted stay from two to three hours.

She also granted permission for a bigger protest, by up to 100 campaigners, on August 27 at the Wyton site.

4
Tweet this article
Report

4 Comments

  • Profile image for Roger_S

    by Roger_S

    Friday, August 05 2011, 2:03PM

    “Onnhoj2010 is correct. Harlan has been publicly exposed twice for breaching basic animal welfare requirements: once in 99 by an undercover investigator (this lead to an EDM signed by around 100MPs calling for its closure which went nowhere) and the second time earlier this year when an ex-employee went public.

    I wasn't aware of a Harlan site in Derbyshire? The nearest one is in Belton (just south of Castle Donington) in Leics as far as I know. What wasn't reported was that Luke Steele has had further restrictions on him as an individual: He's barred from the whole county of Leicestershire and can't arrange or attend any meetings! This is despite all the protests being perfectly legal and having been convicted of nothing!

    It makes me sick how the British Justice System is so corrupt and always sides with big business. I hope NAVA take this as far as the European Courts which tend to be more sympathetic to the rights of the individual.”

  • Profile image for Boohoobloo102

    by Boohoobloo102

    Thursday, August 04 2011, 7:34PM

    “The people walking out if these laboratories deserve everything they get”

  • Profile image for onnhoj2010

    by onnhoj2010

    Thursday, August 04 2011, 4:51PM

    “This company breeds animals for use in experiments and has a proven history of cruelty to animals by its own employees. 'Unsuitable' animals (ie unsuitable to be sold for profit) are routinely killed. Anyone who works for Harlan has on their hands the blood of the millions of animals they have sent to a life of torture, pain and mutilation.
    This is a shameful decision to restrict the legal right to protest, which further proves that the justice system in the UK is run according to the wishes of those with the deepest pockets.”

  • Profile image for msmizzo

    by msmizzo

    Thursday, August 04 2011, 11:51AM

    “What a sensitive little bunch they are, that blood-stained clad protestors are seen as harrassing them, simply by the costumes they wear.
    Right to protest ? Not in this country for much longer, given the news lately.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article