Campaigners' delight as golf course plans are dropped

Trusted article source icon
Tuesday, January 31, 2012
Profile image for Derby Telegraph

Derby Telegraph

CAMPAIGNERS are delighted that plans for an 18-hole golf course that they say would have "destroyed the ambience" of Elvaston Country Park have been dropped.

The developer behind the plans, Highgate Sanctuary, is also scaling back its proposal to turn the site's Grade Two star listed castle into a hotel.

Both changes have been prompted by the disapproval of English Heritage which believed access roads to the course would have "changed the historic layout" of the site.

Derbyshire County Council, owner of Elvaston Castle and country park, says it may now have to retender for a company to take over the attraction.

This is because Highgate's plans are now so different from those originally discussed when the developer was chosen as preferred bidder for the site more than seven years ago.

A spokesman for campaign group Friends of Elvaston Castle said that, despite the lack of progress, he was glad the golf course plan was no more.

He said: "We are delighted that plans so inappropriate for a country park and that would have destroyed its ambience have been dropped but wonder why the council has continued to support this for so long.

"We will continue to dispute any plans that lead to privatisation of the castle itself.

"Making it a tourist attraction again and running it as a Big Society social enterprise is still what we consider to be the best alternative proposal."

An English Heritage spokeswoman said it was worried about two access roads to the course.

She said: "The original proposal for the golf course would have required the roads to be built on the grounds at Elvaston, changing the original historic layout of the registered park and garden, and this was something we had concerns over.

"We also had concerns over the extension because it would have affected the setting of Elvaston, the scale of it was too large and it would have damaged the historical significance of the listed building."

What happens to the castle next would be up to the council, said the spokeswoman.

A new report, mainly paid for by English Heritage, showing what the castle could be used for, says it could become a hotel, a residence, a company's headquarters or a mixture of the three.

It is understood that, if the council did retender, any of these ideas would be considered.

County councillor John Harrison, cabinet member for finance and management, said the authority's legal department was now considering whether this would be necessary.

But Whitehall has already "strongly recommended" that the process take place, as economic conditions are so different to how they were when the tender was first drawn up in 2002.

Mr Harrison said he was unable to set a date for when a planning application could now be made for the castle as "too many balls were still up in the air".

This is despite an earlier report finding that the crumbling castle and grounds needed £6.4 million of repairs.

Most of the golf course itself would not have been built on country park land. But Home Farm, which is on the site, would have been converted into the clubhouse.

Mr Harrison said Highgate bought the land outside the country park from quarrying firm Tarmac and that it would stay in the developer's ownership.

Asked if shelving the golf course plans made it more likely that "initial discussions" held with the National Trust about it taking over the castle's grounds would progress further, Mr Harrison said he was unsure.

Dr Tanya Spilsbury, managing director of Highgate, said the firm was still working with English Heritage and the council on drawing up an acceptable planning application.

She said this process was set for completion in March.

Dr Spilsbury said: "We are looking at a different hotel without the golf course. The new report has made it very clear what English Heritage do and don't want."

5
Tweet this article
Report

5 Comments

  • Profile image for DerbyBorn

    by DerbyBorn

    Tuesday, January 31 2012, 11:57PM

    “onnhoj2010 - I was hoping to go on a tour of all the wonderful Highgate Sanctuary developments - they must be good - otherwise Derbyshire would not have given them a chance to bid (surely).
    I hope that no-one is implying they are nothing but a high intergrity developer of high repute and with an enviable track record.”

  • Profile image for DerbyFoE

    by DerbyFoE

    Tuesday, January 31 2012, 10:48PM

    “Well Done Friends ofEWlvaston Castle - the water on the stone technique continues -
    down periscope

    Derby and South Derbyshire Friends of the Earth”

  • Profile image for onnhoj2010

    by onnhoj2010

    Tuesday, January 31 2012, 9:31AM

    “@DerbyBorn - that would be a very short feature! Interesting that although Norseman Holdings, the company behind Highgate Sanctuary, appears to be involved in the new OneDerby development, the last completed project it lists on its own website was 7 years ago.”

  • Profile image for Bismillah

    by Bismillah

    Tuesday, January 31 2012, 9:31AM

    “I am very pleased that the golf course plans have been quashed. I am and have been a regular visitor to Elvaston my entire life and I do love the place. I have no objections into someone buying the park and even turning it into a hotel as it is such a beautiful building. I think keeping the grounds open to the public is key here as it is well visited and has a historic past of being the first country park of its kind in Britain.”

  • Profile image for DerbyBorn

    by DerbyBorn

    Tuesday, January 31 2012, 8:48AM

    “Telegraph,
    Please can we have a feature on all of the succesful developments that Highgate Sanctuary have completed?”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article