BREAKING NEWS
 

Heated debate on cuts to services dominates final council meeting

Trusted article source icon
Thursday, December 20, 2012
Profile image for Derby Telegraph

Derby Telegraph

DEBATES on cuts to services dominated the last meeting of Derby City Council to be held before the coming year's budget is set.

Members of the public quizzed cabinet members on proposals to reduce funding to help support people facing homelessness, the halving of cash spent on a unit which supports child victims of sex abuse and the introduction of charging to collect brown bins.

  1. Ranjit Bainwait

  2. Ranjit Banwait said  charges for  blue badge parking were being reconsidered.

    Ranjit Banwait said charges for blue badge parking were being reconsidered.

Efforts by Conservatives to get money put into the budget to keep biodiversity group WildDerby going and prevent the need to introduce charging for blue badge holders in council car parks were both defeated.

Instead each motion was met with a Labour amendment urging the Tories to come up with alternative options backed by research and figures.

Business Cards From Only £10.95 Delivered www.myprint-247.co.uk

myprint-247

View details

Print voucher

Our heavyweight cards have FREE UV silk coating, FREE next day delivery & VAT included. Choose from 1000's of pre-designed templates or upload your own artwork. Orders dispatched within 24hrs.

Terms: Visit our site for more products: Business Cards, Compliment Slips, Letterheads, Leaflets, Postcards, Posters & much more. All items are free next day delivery. www.myprint-247.co.uk

Contact: 01858 468192

Valid until: Friday, May 31 2013

On the issue of blue badge parking, Councillor Ranjit Banwait said: "We are exploring alternatives because Labour councillor and disability champion Paul Pegg came to us and is working with us on alternatives – you need to offer up alternatives like that."

Councillor Martin Rawson did offer hope for the child sex abuse unit in Leopold street, which supports victims, however.

Following concerns highlighted in the Derby Telegraph, Mr Rawson said he had ordered officers to see if the unit could instead be offered to other authorities for a charge to help achieve the £100,000 needed to balance the budget instead of cutting the service.

In answer to a question from member of the public Mary Johnson, Mr Rawson said: "I'm extremely sympathetic to the case you are putting forward. I have asked officers to do some further work."

But there was strong debate on litter.

Tories argued against the "brown bin tax" which will see residents being asked to pay £40 a year to have their brown bin emptied, and criticised Mr Banwait's litter campaign which saw rubbish going uncollected for a weekend in the city centre.

Councillor Matthew Holmes, Tory deputy leader, called it "disgraceful" and a "political stunt".

And fellow Tory Chris Poulter also argued it had undermined the work to clean up.

While the parties argued on the methods employed to keep the city clean, there was cross-party support for the Telegraph's Clean Up Derby campaign, which highlights the city's worst litter hotspots in a bid to prompt action to tackle them.

Mr Poulter's motion to make the council ensure sufficient staffing was in place to support the Clean Up Derby campaign was defeated, however.

Instead a Labour amendment highlighting the council's litter campaign work and that of the Telegraph was passed.

Mr Poulter said: "I will put aside the political point scoring of Labour on this issue."

But he added that he failed to see how it could be achieved without the budget to support the work.

The next meeting of the full council will be in January when the budget is set.

0
Tweet this article
Report

Comments

  • Profile image for Derby_born

    by Derby_born

    Friday, December 21 2012, 9:36PM

    “Here is another report from this newspaper concerning the freeze on Council Tax:

    "DERBYSHIRE County Council will receive nearly £3 million from the Government after announcing it will freeze council tax in 2013-14".

    "Labour-run Derby City Council will not receive a grant as it plans to increase council tax by almost 2% from April next year".

    http://tinyurl.com/cetfy6m

  • Profile image for asctty

    by asctty

    Friday, December 21 2012, 9:18PM

    “I hope Ramjet Bandwagon takes note of his publicist's poll findings over the brown bin tax.”

  • Profile image for Derby_born

    by Derby_born

    Friday, December 21 2012, 8:28PM

    “the Telegraph poll on the "brown bin tax" has so far shown people are overwhelmingly against the £40 a year charge.

    Telegraph poll:

    Are you in favour of a "brown bin tax" proposed by Derby City Council?

    92%Absolutely not
    8%I am, yes”

  • Profile image for Santa___Claus

    by Santa___Claus

    Friday, December 21 2012, 1:22PM

    “by Rob09
    "The Council are having to cut services ...."

    NO The Councile does not HAVE to cut services. It choses to cut services rather than cut back on its profligate spending on fancy council houses, overpaid executives, etcetera.

    Like every Labour administration both local and national this rotten council plays politics with peoples lives.”

  • Profile image for kessie2012

    by kessie2012

    Friday, December 21 2012, 12:04PM

    “what a joke this council is ..im not a voter as i would not want to be part of a group who say i voted for them id be ashamed . im not a conservative either but there was one thing done right when they were in power .the city was cleaner .chris poulter did an excellent job .all along embankments was litter free bins were emptied .my black bin at pressent gets enptied every 11 weeks then i have to ring up still nothing a useless machine .now i have mc glughlans number ill hound him again my black bin was last emptied on the 27/10/12 brown one over 2 years ago and they now want £40 thats a joke surely bring back poulter . there was one thing also about phillip hickson he was truthful not like bayliss lie to his constuates to get votes anti incineratoin garbage he told alvaston no incinerator then he tries to buy land on raynesway to put it there ,what a 2 faced leader total disgrace .”

  • Profile image for OllyB1

    by OllyB1

    Friday, December 21 2012, 1:27AM

    “And they have only just finished spending £35m on their own plush office block!”

  • Profile image for LittleoverSim

    by LittleoverSim

    Friday, December 21 2012, 1:15AM

    “@Rob09 the council has £10 million it could spend on those valuable services if it did not look to pay over the odds for the Sinfin incinerator. The fact they look to pay £25 million instead of a 30% share which would be £15 million shows how badly the council budget !”

  • Profile image for DerbyFoE

    by DerbyFoE

    Friday, December 21 2012, 12:34AM

    “Interesting points Sim - lots of high gloss around at the moment

    We received a refusal to answer our question regarding the proposed reduction in educational resources for children, regarding climate change. The question was if this was so that children wouldn't find out about the 172,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide to be pumped into the air above them, from the proposed Derby incinerator, by burning the food waste that people would end up throwing into the blackbin,( NB The 5 yr old prototype for Derby - the incinerator in the Isle of Wight which has breached dioxin limits by 800%, is to be shut down next year) People would be forced to throw such foodwaste in the blackbin if a reduced expensive brown bin service was introduced instead and the Council have admitted that recycling rates would thus drop. Fine tenet of Sustainable Development that is.........

    Motion 6 regarding this, is coercive, trying to equate keeping brown bin services with saving childrens centres - making it seem as though those dastardly brown bins would harm children's futures, if we kept them. Some sort of mistake shurely?

    Derby and South Derbyshire Friends of the Earth”

  • Profile image for davsl

    by davsl

    Thursday, December 20 2012, 10:23PM

    “Yes but that's another 90p per week out of my pension”

  • Profile image for make_redgreen

    by make_redgreen

    Thursday, December 20 2012, 10:03PM

    “What I'd love to know, is that if the deficit is still rising, where are all these 'cuts'?

    I'm guessing savings in one area means payrises in another.

    In fact, I'm not guessing, I know ;) :(”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Be the first to comment

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article