Street lights switch-off 'may leave elderly isolated'

Trusted article source icon
Wednesday, February 01, 2012
Profile image for Derby Telegraph

Derby Telegraph

THE boss of an elderly people's charity in Derbyshire says that a decision to switch off up to 40,000 of the county's street lights for part of the night could lead to an "increased feeling of isolation" among older people.

Age UK chief executive Katy Pugh made the comment after Derbyshire County Council yesterday confirmed it would turn off the lamps from midnight to 5.30am.

But Mrs Pugh said it was "probably one of the least damaging ways for the authority to save money".

The council said the move would cut £400,000 a year from its energy bill and reduce its annual carbon output by 2,000 tonnes.

It said the switch-off would take three or four years, starting in April and taking place in separate areas at different times.

There will be a four-week public consultation with each affected community, which may lead to "minor adjustment" of local schemes.

Another 900 of the county's 89,000 lamps will be switched off altogether.

Mrs Pugh said it was important that the council gave plenty of notice so people could add lighting outside their homes if necessary.

She said it could also be an issue for some carers who visit older people at night.

Mrs Pugh said: "Looking out of the window and not seeing any lights on could lead to a sense that people cannot go out even if they want to or a sense of fear."

Helen Clark, chairman of Erewash Labour Local Government Committee, has been campaigning against the switch-off on the grounds of risk to public safety.

She said the move, coupled with a reduction in police officers, was creating a "criminals' charter".

Mrs Clark said a Labour party survey of 311 people in Ockbrook and Borrowash found 91% disagreed with the plans.

But a council report on the switch-off said the survey did not provide respondents with enough background information about the proposals.

Councillor Simon Spencer, cabinet member for highways and transport, said the aim of the scheme was "not to plunge Derbyshire into darkness".

He said: "We'll look carefully at every area before we switch any lights off and there are many areas, town centres and high crime areas for example, where we won't switch any lights off at all."

22
Tweet this article
Report

22 Comments

  • Profile image for Movg4wdintheQ

    by Movg4wdintheQ

    Friday, February 03 2012, 8:58PM

    “I'd love to lower the glow of the 90000000 million lux light that shines into my bedroom.

    Lights - fine - need them to see; but in a quiet suburban crescent all they do is help criminals to see where they're going!

    Light doesn't help blind people, elderly people or any community if it's inappropriate; my street lights are motorway standard - go away!”

  • Profile image for tillo1

    by tillo1

    Friday, February 03 2012, 2:35PM

    “@Roadscource,yes,I'm buried in Golders Green Cemetery,I only come out at night and I like a little bit of light.I'm on an "Endless Sleep",check out the song.bolan.”

  • Profile image for coralsea

    by coralsea

    Friday, February 03 2012, 7:30AM

    “What about solar powered lighting or just having street lighting on just on one side of the street,
    Just a thought.
    I hate the fact that we are being held to ransom by Derby city council, they have our money and thinhk they have a unique right as to how they spend OUR!!! money.”

  • Profile image for Purple_T

    by Purple_T

    Thursday, February 02 2012, 8:55PM

    “@dave15248
    No dave, why should i have to change and have my hair cut like them, or dress like them. Surely it's the vile thugs that should have to change!
    How boring it would be if we all had to walk around like clones!”

  • Profile image for krob2

    by krob2

    Thursday, February 02 2012, 7:47PM

    “A very retrograde step I think - 5.30 is too late for a morning switch on, people ARE out after midnight - especially weekends.

    Around here you have assault course streets with randomly parked vehicles everywhere. Its bound to add to accidents. Sure we have headlights but street lights do make a big difference.”

  • Profile image for Roadscource

    by Roadscource

    Thursday, February 02 2012, 5:12PM

    “Bolan?

    Is this story somehow connected to T Rex !”

  • Profile image for dave15248

    by dave15248

    Thursday, February 02 2012, 4:48PM

    “That's truly shocking purple_t getting constantly attacked, did you think about becoming a 'trendy'? sounds like it would have saved you a thumping or two.”

  • Profile image for tillo1

    by tillo1

    Thursday, February 02 2012, 2:05PM

    “@Green******,what a prat,I work nights and sometimes my shift does not start until 1am,while you are tucked up in bed I'm going to work,what a stupid comment,bolan.”

  • Profile image for scratchyitup

    by scratchyitup

    Thursday, February 02 2012, 1:15PM

    “Turn them off and give us a refund.”

  • Profile image for BocBoc

    by BocBoc

    Thursday, February 02 2012, 12:35PM

    “"People drive on unlit roads all the time, so why a problem if every second light is turned off? Or even if all are turned off? You have car lights for nighttime driving"

    I agree with this - especially on motorways”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters