Wind 'not strong enough' to claim for chimney fall
A HOUSEHOLDER whose chimney fell off his roof in yesterday's gales was stunned when he was told by his insurer: "You can't claim because the wind wasn't strong enough."
Jason Ryalls was woken up at 5.30am by a loud bang and opened his front door to see masonry had fallen on a car outside.
He said he phoned Legal & General – only to be told it would only pay out if winds were "storm force" – above 45mph – and it said yesterday's gales had not reached that figure.
The firm changed its mind only after the Derby Telegraph – alerted by an amazed Mr Ryalls – called to query the decision.
A company spokeswoman said the high-tech system it used to measure the weather had previously shown winds in the morning were not strong enough for a claim.
But she said: "We've looked at it again and the records have been updated to show the winds were higher."
Mr Ryalls, 35, said: "They've said they might be prepared to pay it and have apologised."
The district manager for KFC restaurants, who lives in the terraced house with girlfriend Chelsea Anderson and their four-year-old daughter, Teikia, added: "What they said was absolutely ridiculous – I haven't seen winds this strong for many years."
The Met Office said winds in the East Midlands early yesterday morning, when the chimney fell from Mr Ryalls' home in Slack Lane, Derby, were "gale force", gusting at up to 54mph.
The Legal & General spokeswoman said: "We now need to go out and make sure the property is in good condition before making a decision on whether it is a valid claim."
Yesterday's high winds and heavy rain caused disruption throughout the day, with falling trees delaying motorists on roads including the A38 at Burton and the A608 at Heanor.
In Church Street, Church Gresley, a tree smashed into a car and in Repton Road, Hartshorne, branches damaged phone lines.
Firefighters wearing waterproof suits had to give a van driver a piggyback after his vehicle became engulfed at a ford near Ashbourne.
And wind and rain caused power cuts at 1,000 homes in places such as Melbourne, Woodville, Morley and Belper. Western Power said these homes all had power restored by yesterday afternoon.
Dean Gazzard, station manager at Derbyshire fire service's headquarters, said the van rescue had happened at a ford across Henmore Brook, in Green Lane, Hangingbridge.
The driver misjudged the depth of the rising waters, becoming stuck at 8.45am.
Mr Gazzard said: "Police got there first and informed us. The driver had gone into the ford. But there was about a 2ft of fast flowing water.
"It picked the van up and span it around so that it hit the bank."
He said the driver felt "uncomfortable" about getting out and was given a piggy back by firefighters wearing waterproof suits. Mr Gazzard said: "I don't think there was much damage to the van, perhaps just a bit of damage to the driver's pride."
A county council spokeswoman said more than 40 of its workers had been out since the early hours of yesterday clearing trees from about 30 roads.
The A608 Church Street/Mansfield Road, Heanor, was shut because of a fallen tree, with drivers diverted along Hands Road
Other blockages included Robin Hood Road and Longway Bank, Whatstandwell; Coton Road, Walton-on-Trent; Ash Lane, Etwall; and the A517 at Hulland Ward.
A spokesman for traffic information company Traffic Link said drivers faced delays of up to 45 minutes on the A38 with a tree blocking the northbound carriageway at Burton for about four hours.
The Environment Agency issued flood alerts for parts of the River Trent, River Dove and River Derwent in Derbyshire, but said that river levels were receding last night.
Helen Chivers, Met Office forecaster, said "calmer weather" was expected today.









5 Comments
by Littleoverlad
Friday, January 06 2012, 12:44PM
“Insurance companies are the source of all evil”
by janine2011
Friday, January 06 2012, 11:21AM
“My insurance comes through the Derbyshire Building Society and one of the companies they used initially refused to pay out when my tropical fish tank leaked whilst I was on holiday. They told me it wasn't covered by my policy.I asked them did they record calls when amendments were made to policies and they said they did, I told them to find the recording when I added the tank to my insurance as there was no way it wasn't covered. Hey presto loss adjuster visited, sorted it out, sent me the money to replace the carpet as the company they used couldn't offer me anything like the colour and quality I had, and as I chose not to have another tank, the money it cost to buy.”
by dianae
Friday, January 06 2012, 10:24AM
“This kind of story means that some people - esp those hard pressed to keep a bit of cash back at end of month - will ditch the insurance as "companies will do all they can not to pay out anyway" and then if there is a fire, flood or similar people will be left with nothing.
Legal and General (and any other company who tries it on like this) deserves the bad publicity it got - one for not checking properly with the Met Office and two for having that kind of blanket rule anyway - gusts of wind are not uniform. The Met Office site may record a highest gust just below storm force and somewhere 5 miles away can easily have gusts stronger than that.
When you find an insurance company that acts fairly stick with it - others may give you rubbish service like this one tried to do.”
by sabta_claus
Friday, January 06 2012, 10:04AM
“Typical insurance company - happy to take premiums, but will look for any excuse not to pay out.
No doubt the next excuse will be "act of God" - whoever or whatever he is.”
by littlemoaner
Friday, January 06 2012, 9:42AM
“man phones insurance company early the next morning mere hours after an incident
insurance company make a genuine mistake as data had not yet been updated
man straight onto newspaper rather than query himself and try to resolve
insurance company quickly acknowledge mistake and apologise
Well blow me over if this is newsworthy!!
still - eat more fried chicken folks, the manager has a chimney and car repairs to pay for”