BREAKING NEWS
 

Victoria Martindale: Where's the NHS compassion towards animals on its menu?

Trusted article source icon
Tuesday, December 04, 2012
Profile image for Derby Telegraph

Derby Telegraph

ONE of the six values that lies at the heart of everything the NHS does is compassion: a commitment to humanity and kindness.

Get ready to be shocked. The NHS serves most of its meals from animals reared in some of the worst welfare conditions allowed by law in this country, and Derby hospitals rank among the lowest.

Ninety-nine per cent of eggs served at the Royal Derby Hospital and London Road Community Hospital come from battery hens.

These hens spend their entire lives in barren, over-crowded cages unable to spread their wings and are denied the ability to express any natural behaviour, such as scratching about, making nests or dust bathing.

SAVE 30% ON YOUR PAYDAY LOAN

Meetthelenders

View details

Print voucher

visit us at www.meetthelenders.co.uk/blogs to Save 30% off your loan fees with Quick Quid, Read our article for instructions

Contact: 0115 8962299

Valid until: Friday, May 31 2013

All of the chicken and pork served at Derby hospitals comes from farms that fail to meet the minimal standards that the RSPCA deems necessary in terms of animal welfare.

The housing and rearing conditions of these poor creatures is abysmal, failing to offer any kind of quality of life and forcing them to live a lifetime of confinement and distress before a terrifying and horrific premature death.

This information, revealed by the RSPCA and the national Campaign for Better Hospital Food group, highlights an underlying contradiction between the image of the NHS as an all-caring, kindhearted bastion of compassion and empathy and its support for the most appalling conditions found in the intensive factory farming business.

It cuts to the heart of the NHS as a compassionate institution of our society.

It repudiates the values that lie at its core and suggests that the sensibilities of our NHS apply solely and exclusively to members of one species while a very different set of values applies to every other.

I cannot fathom how any establishment, let alone one like the NHS, can cherish one species as the most important in this universe to the extent that any other non-human animal is beyond its sphere of compassion.

When other sentient creatures experience suffering and pain in just the same way as we do, it seems strange how a universal value can be applied so selectively.

For the NHS to serve meals of such an appallingly low animal welfare standard on one hand while we are led to regard it as the most compassionate sector of society on the other suggests quite remarkable arrogance and lack of sympathy.

More fundamentally, the NHS has an obligation to endorse and be seen to endorse nothing but the highest standards of compassion and care without discrimination.

Yet serving these meals does anything but this and undermines its own ethos.

The NHS should show it really is a caring service and ensure all its meals meet the animal welfare standards expected by consumers and, at a minimum, meet RSPCA Freedom Food standards.

Cage-free conditions are a step in the right direction to fulfil the NHS value of compassion that it claims lies at the heart of everything it does.

0
Tweet this article
Report

Comments

  • Profile image for debvegandeb

    by debvegandeb

    Thursday, December 13 2012, 2:25AM

    “a good example of stupidity, obese patient in hospital waiting for op, had to lose a stone before he could go for gastric band , costing £250 per day bed use, the staff had him on a diet, then the sweet trolley coming round twice a day, same as patients who are in for heart attacks then dish out bacon or egg sandwiches/sausages, that food alone is the biggest killer going, I TELL YOU NOW, HUMANS ARE ALL FOR THEM SELVES AND THEIR LIFE, DO YOU REALLY THINK THEY CARE ABOUT OTHER INDIVIDUALS?, HUMAN OR NON-HUMAN, no its a job with coffee breaks a wage and a feel good factor. deep down every one is laughing, no one gives a damn about humans so why should they give a damn about animals,”

  • Profile image for Spildabeenz

    by Spildabeenz

    Thursday, December 06 2012, 12:43PM

    “shadam
    You hit the nail on the there.... It is shocking that people have to feed their own families for no other reason than the hospital food is so poor.

    I am lucky enough to get private healthcare through work. If I lost my job, I would still probably continue to pay the premiums myself if my next employer didn't offer to. I had an operation three years ago and the food was really good. If it can be done, then it should be done for all, private or not.”

  • Profile image for shadam

    by shadam

    Thursday, December 06 2012, 11:17AM

    “Ahhhh, wondered why the food was inedible. Its funny, but when there is talk about waste within the NHS, it usually involves resources to do with patient care, however, having recently had my mother and daughter in hospital, nobody questioned why the food trays were taken back untouched, or, why we were taking sandwiches in for my daughter particularly.
    Adequate nutrition is paramount for individuals who are unwell, for whatever reason. I clearly remember asking patients why they were not eating, and, the kitchen staff came to the wards to talk with patients who had complaints about the food. This has all gone by the board now at the super RDH, (sarcasm intended)”

  • Profile image for Antony_Rol

    by Antony_Rol

    Thursday, December 06 2012, 8:23AM

    “But John I think the point that people where trying to make is that -
    1.regarding the food being private (as even non private patients get the choice) you would not be forced to eat meat, as there is a veggie option. Therefore I presume you caught food poisoning (if the story is true) from a vegetarian meal. Rendering your point null and void
    2. You suggest humans are on equal footing with animals, but then suggest humans, from other countries to your own are inferior and should not be afforded basic healthcare unless they have paid into 'the system' - can you not see the hypocrisy in what you write?

    ...all of which is only very teniously related to the original article, having been dragged off topic by yourself, again

    What would happen if your Aliens that landed where vegetarian and laid eggs, would you eat the eggs or enslave the aliens?”

  • Profile image for superacetrace

    by superacetrace

    Thursday, December 06 2012, 1:40AM

    “Last stay i had in hospital,my rocket lettuce was a pitiful sight to see.
    You can get food poisoning from veggies too BTW.
    One of the worst offenders for non meat related food poisoning is rice.”

  • Profile image for Cymru_Ddraig

    by Cymru_Ddraig

    Thursday, December 06 2012, 1:24AM

    “by Spitfireking
    .Yet now you are on about keeping NHS services for UK citizens only and cutting overseas aid.


    There is nothing inconsistent in what I have said. Only in your determination to twist it to your own ends.
    Why should we bail out countries that are RICHER than us, like India and China ?”

  • Profile image for stolen_ID

    by stolen_ID

    Thursday, December 06 2012, 12:10AM

    “That's odd John that you should say the NHS gave you food poisoning a year ago, when about a year ago you wrote on these same pages (under one of your many previous guises) that you do not use the NHS as you go private for your healthcare
    I'm pretty sure it was on the same story where you accused meat eaters of smelling of rotting flesh, a story about smoking if I remember correctly
    So along your lines of selective health treatment, how about the NHS stops treating smokers, that should save them a Bob or two they can divert into ethical sourcing of food”

  • Profile image for Spitfireking

    by Spitfireking

    Wednesday, December 05 2012, 11:33PM

    “@Cymru_Ddraig

    Do you actually read what you type!!!

    Do the words "…sub human, with no rights. Now we know better." Ring any bells with you??? They are words you put on this website. Yet now you are on about keeping NHS services for UK citizens only and cutting overseas aid.

    I am getting visions of a windsock again.”

  • Profile image for Cymru_Ddraig

    by Cymru_Ddraig

    Wednesday, December 05 2012, 11:22PM

    “by Spitfireking
    All those who wish the NHS to provide free range (insert animal produce) are you also happy to pay more taxes to get it or should the NHS cut budgets elsewhere?"


    1) They could start by not treating foreign health tourists.
    2) The fact that they pay for agency staff is a disgrace.
    3) There are too many tiers of uneccessary management costing a fortune.
    4) Perhaps governmewnt should divert funds into the NHS instead of wasting it on overseas aid to countries like India & China, and should stop paying child benefit to east europeans.”

  • Profile image for Cymru_Ddraig

    by Cymru_Ddraig

    Wednesday, December 05 2012, 11:17PM

    “by stolen_ID
    And are you suggesting that the NHS and their subcontracted catering companies are responsible for giving people food poisoning?
    That's quite a statement to make, I hope you have some evidence for such a serious allegation Cymru_Ddraig?"



    Yes, personal experience a year ago.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Be the first to comment

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article