Women beating men to council top jobs

Trusted article source icon
Tuesday, November 10, 2009
Profile image for This is Derbyshire

This is Derbyshire

WOMEN now outnumber men in the top jobs at Derbyshire's two biggest councils, new figures show.

More than half of the senior managers at the city and county council are female. In Derby, 53.4% of workers in the top five per cent best-paid are women, while the figure at County Hall is 55.7%.

That puts both authorities near the top of the UK league table for councils employing a high proportion of women in senior positions – and smashes the comparison with the private sector, where only 12% of bosses are female.

Both authorities have hailed the statistics as proof that family-friendly policies are enabling female employees to reach their full potential, breaking through the so-called "glass ceiling" – and setting an example for UK industry to follow.

Ann Webster, equality and diversity consultant at Derby City Council, said: "Let's just say women have put some significant cracks in the glass ceiling, but there are still things we can do to improve.

"It is important to have a mix (of male and female managers) because we want equality. I would hate to think people at the council felt top jobs were just for men."

Councillor John Harrison, Derbyshire County Council's cabinet member for finance and management, said: "These figures confirm that the county council treats its employees equally and ensures flexible, family-friendly working opportunities to encourage a good work/lifestyle balance."

Christine Durrant is one of the city's most senior female employees, as an assistant director in the city's regeneration department. She said: "I have always had people around me who are very supportive and I have been able to move on and get different experience."

Engineer Ms Durrant, responsible for highways and transportation, joined the authority in 1997 as principal traffic and transportation engineer, and was gradually given more responsibility, rising to head of transportation and then to assistant director level. With two young children, she knows the importance of the work-life balance, but said once she had set her mind to working full-time, she had no problems achieving it.

"It is a balance of being prepared to put yourself out when you need to, but also people appreciate that the most important thing in life is not work and that is a good culture to have."

Under Government rules, councils must keep track of how many women are among their top five per cent of earners. These figures show the city and county are within the top 10% of authorities for employing women in senior posts.

In the city, the top five per cent start at a salary of £34,207. In the county it is £38,500.

In the city, 272 of the 509 top earners are women. The city council has seen an increase in the number of women among its top 5% earners, from 49.2% in 2006-7, to 51.2% in 2007-8 and then 53.44% in 2008-9.

Councillor Mike Carr, city cabinet member for direct and internal services, said: "We promote a good work-life balance at the city council and our flexi-time system means people who have to put extra hours in on certain occasions get that time back."

The figures for the percentage of women employed in top positions in district authorities is much lower, however.

For the latest Audit Commission-audited figures covering 2008-08, just 11.11% of Amber Valley Borough Council's top earners were women. For Derbyshire Dales District Council it was 15.38%, Erewash Borough Council 33.33% and South Derbyshire District Council was 17.65%.

A spokesman for Amber Valley Borough Council said: "The council has a stable management team and few senior positions have become available in recent years. Amber Valley Borough Council's actual management team consists of six men and two women."

A Government equality spokeswoman said private sector companies should be following the example of Derby and Derbyshire councils.

"It is more important than ever that big businesses draw on all the talent available to them and the best way to do that is to employ women in the boardroom, not just on the shop floor," she said.

Under equality legislation, all councils have been ordered to check how much they pay workers to ensure similarly-qualified employees take home the same money. Bonuses traditionally paid to male workers in manual jobs are being scrapped. The move means some employees will get more money, and others less.

39
Tweet this article
Report

39 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Derbyshire

    by Jo, Derbys

    Wednesday, November 11 2009, 10:36AM

    “Funnily enough, there's a discussion about employment of female Archbishops this am
    on Woman's Hour(R.4); a female is campaigning against- and a prominent man in the church championing!
    I suppose it's all about democracy, and representation of the sexes, which is about 50/50 in the population.”

  • Profile image for This is Derbyshire

    by Vis, 5 Lamps

    Tuesday, November 10 2009, 3:57PM

    “Womens hour on radio bore (4)
    where's men's hour then?”

  • Profile image for This is Derbyshire

    by Angela, Derby

    Tuesday, November 10 2009, 3:57PM

    “Dragon, I have to agree with your comment,”

  • Profile image for This is Derbyshire

    by Jo, Derbys

    Tuesday, November 10 2009, 3:52PM

    “Chris- I believe in sharing of roles between sexes, as fairer and more practical.
    I think this is a reality in many European countries, and it's no big deal, and certainly nothing to fear!

    As regards Europe, I'd far rather have closer links there than only American politics, which is what seemed to have happened in th 80's onwards.
    Although I really like Obama!”

  • Profile image for This is Derbyshire

    by Robert, Derby

    Tuesday, November 10 2009, 3:51PM

    “Perhaps more of a story should be what exactly these people do at the council, male & female for their salaries?
    Ms Durrant, you must have a vehicle with excellent suspension, because every road in derby seems riddled with potholes only you don't seem to notice them.”

  • Profile image for This is Derbyshire

    by Dragon, Derby

    Tuesday, November 10 2009, 3:47PM

    “Harriet Harman is constantly spouting on about "womens rights" and "positive discrimination" and so on.

    All I can say is if she is an example of a woman in a top job God help us all.

    I think she should follow the example of the original womens movement and burn her bra - preferably while shes still wearing it.”

  • Profile image for This is Derbyshire

    by Christopher, Derby

    Tuesday, November 10 2009, 3:47PM

    “Error occured! Sorry my last comment posted twice after adding final comment without actually clicking on the submit button.

    This discussion reminds me of the Monty Python sketch where men were the house-keepers whilst women went to work, was funny at the time but may turn out to be "prophetic".
    Jo,
    the European situation has been imposed on us by stealth over a long period of time, things will change in Europe by the time we become part of a European Federal state.”

  • Profile image for This is Derbyshire

    by Jo, Derbys

    Tuesday, November 10 2009, 3:41PM

    “Much of this topic has been well documented by Jenni Marray on Woman's Hour(Radio 4)- and many men interviewed also.Also the programme is poular with men, many of whom would like to see fairer practices in the workplace.”

  • Profile image for This is Derbyshire

    by Jo, Derbys

    Tuesday, November 10 2009, 3:38PM

    “Chris- why has your comment appeared again above mine?!”

  • Profile image for This is Derbyshire

    by Christopher, Derby

    Tuesday, November 10 2009, 3:37PM

    “Maggie Thatcher was a dominant leader, she was as equally brutal towards the male cabinet members as she was to the female members, Maggie loved Maggie. I have met Edwina Currie on several occasions and she seemed to be very approachable and did say that she wanted to see more female MPs.

    Equality should not be based upon a quota system, it should be based solely on ability to do the job. I was once chosen for a job over 8 female applicants, it was a tech job within the Education Service. I was chosen 1, because I proved that I was capable of doing he job and 2, (so I was told when I had been in the job for 6 months) I was working with 7 women and they said that they wanted to have some male company in the office! I was pleased that my ability to do the job came as first consideration. All the women were older than me! But I did not feel threatened by this in any way, I had a great job for three whole years until our department closed down.
    I think is harder for a man to get any job within the public sector these days due to this belief that discrimination towards male applicants in favour of improving female job prospects is a"positive" thing.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters